Meet In Middle-Earth - closing
    > The Books
        > The Sword that was broken
New Topic    Add Reply

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>
Author
Comment
Andranneth
Administrator
Posts: 223
(10/29/05 1:38 am)
Reply

The Sword that was broken
Thinking through the scene at the Prancing Pony again I stumbled across something that always has been bugging me a little. So far as I tend to do with book, I just ignored that little bumb and read on. But now I think it might be interesting to discuss it:

"I did not know," he answered. "But I am Aagorn, and those verses go with that name." He drew out his sword, and they saw that the blade was indeed broken a foot below the hilt. "Not much use is it, Sa? said Strider. "But the time is near when it shall be forged anew."

Think about it. Who in his right mind would go about with a broken sword, heir loom or not? The world is dangerous enough with a fully usable blade at hand. It's just something I find odd.

That is one of the rare points when I credit the movies for having come up with a more reasonable and logical solution - having the blade being kept safe in Rivendell - up to the point where it should have been reforged after the council.

Ithiloth
Administrator
Posts: 46
(10/29/05 4:13 pm)
Reply

Re: The Sword that was broken
You know, you are right. I always assumed he had a good sword too, but now that I think about it, it isn't said. So in this sense, I do think Peter Jackson was right in the movie to leave the shards of Narsil back in Rivendell, safe and honored, until the time came for the blade to be brought forth in full, re-forged use.

Interesting. Why did Aragorn carry the shards of the sword with him? Could it be that he was never sure when he might have to make his claim to the throne of Gondor? Or was it a more useful weapon against Sauron's minions than a broken sword? For Sauron lost the war and physical form because of that broken sword, and so that piece might have scared enemies of the dark lord....and yet, if Aragorn drew it with anything like frequency, word would have gotten round that the heir of Isildur lived and was (wherever he had been spotted). And that would have gotten Sauron to looking for him specifically...which he did anyway, but not so openly as he would have had to had he known for sure just where Aragorn was, carrying that broken but still powerful sword.

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>

Add Reply

Email This To a Friend Email This To a Friend
Topic Control Image Topic Commands
Click to receive email notification of replies Click to receive email notification of replies
Click to stop receiving email notification of replies Click to stop receiving email notification of replies
jump to:

- Meet In Middle-Earth - closing - The Books -

Powered By ezboard® Ver. 7.32
Copyright ©1999-2007 ezboard, Inc.